top of page

Emerson Colonial Theatre’s Suspenseful ‘Paranormal Activity’ Proves That the Horror Genre Deserves a Place on Stage

Sep 29
3 min read

Updated: Nov 13


Photo: Matthew Murphy
Photo: Matthew Murphy

*Written as a mockup review exercise after the production's conclusion.


When seeing a production such as the Paranormal Activity, it’s understandable why one might enter with a sense of curiosity mixed with unflinching excitement and nervous anticipation. It’s not every day that a horror movie transitions from screen to stage, and when it does, the results can be as unsettling as the source material.


But the powers that be seem to have smiled upon Playwright Levi Holloway and Director Felix Barrett, whose new production of Paranormal Activity concluded its pre-Broadway run at Boston’s historic Emerson Colonial Theatre. Its next stop? The August Wilson Theatre in New York City, where it will begin a limited Broadway run through January 3, 2027.


At face value, theatregoers might view this play with apprehension. Theatre and the horror genre have had a historically complicated relationship. Taking a horror story from screen to stage can lead to productions like Beetlejuice – a hit with younger audiences that’s already had multiple national tours – or Carrie, whose brief run in the ‘80s flopped due to a myriad of issues (including fake blood interfering with body mics). But in Paranormal Activity, the marriage between these mediums surprisingly – and fortunately – works. 


The show’s plot breaks away from franchise canon by introducing us to two new characters, James and Lou (played by Travis A. Knight and Cher Álvarez). The newly-married couple have just moved to their new home in London for a fresh start. But while they may be trying to escape the past, the past is not yet through with them. It becomes evident that an entity has followed them to their new home; one which has a particular interest in Lou. As supernatural events begin to occur and intensify, James and Lou must overcome struggles within their marriage and themselves, while simultaneously facing the malevolent being that has turned their home into an inescapable nightmare.


As James and Lou, Travis A. Knight and Cher Álvarez click effortlessly. Their natural chemistry and dynamic creates a natural flow throughout their scenes; with both actors simultaneously holding their own as individuals and exploring their characters’ complex emotional journeys with ease.


Fly Davis’ set design is a particularly noteworthy element of this production. The layout mirrors a two-story open dollhouse, and is visually appealing to the eye. This is in part due to the enriching prop details throughout the home’s kitchen and living room, but primarily because of what is arguably the most important factor in a horror production: the scares. 


Those who have seen the Paranormal Activity movie will know that it’s not what’s happening in front of you that’s unnerving. It’s what’s happening down the hall or up the stairs, where you’re not looking. In the films, this activity is captured on home security cameras. But thanks to the uniquely-omniscient layout of the set, audiences can see every room, all the time. This quality does an impeccable job at building suspense; as James and Lou converse on the living room couch, your eyes can’t help but wander to the darkened rooms upstairs, in anticipation of who – or what – might be lurking in the shadows. 


But rest assured, this show’s biggest scares are not subtle. They announce themselves in surprising and unexpected ways, eliciting shocked gasps from audience members undoubtedly wondering, “How did they pull that off?” The show has an optimal ratio of suspense, scares, twists, and plot-driven character development, creating an atmosphere that’s both spooky and fun at the same time. 


This production does not come without its flaws. There are loose ends in the script which remain untied and unclarified. A character recovers too quickly from a jarring supernatural encounter that would leave most homeowners sprinting towards the nearest exit. The ominous upstairs rooms – while providing an atmospheric sense of foreboding – are ultimately underutilized when it comes to scares, resulting in an uneven balance of suspense and payoff. The minimal props on the home’s second floor – particularly on the walls – are striking when compared to the detail-oriented nature of the main level. 


But despite its imperfections, Paranormal Activity remains a unique production that is unlike anything most theatregoers have seen before. It satisfies those looking for suspense, scares, and thrills, and makes a strong case for why horror does indeed deserve a place on the stage. 


‘Paranormal Activity’ — Presented at the Emerson Colonial Theatre from July 11-30, 2026.


For more information, please visit https://paranormalbroadway.com/


 
 

© 2026 by Megan Murphy. Powered and secured by Wix 

bottom of page